Metal release and metal allergy after total hip replacement with resurfacing versus conventional hybrid prosthesis.

Metal release and metal allergy after total hip replacement with resurfacing versus conventional hybrid prosthesis.

Acta orthopaedica (2014-06-17)

Klas Gustafson, Stig S Jakobsen, Nina D Lorenzen, Jacob P Thyssen, Jeanne D Johansen, Charlotte M Bonefeld, Maiken Stilling, Thomas Baad-Hansen, Kjeld Søballe

PMID24930546

ABSTRACT

Metal-on-metal (MOM) total hip arthroplasties were reintroduced because of the problems with osteolysis and aseptic loosening related to polyethylene wear of early metal-on-polyethylene (MOP) arthroplasties. The volumetric wear rate has been greatly reduced with MOM arthroplasties; however, because of nano-size wear particles, the absolute number has been greatly increased. Thus, a source of metal ion exposure with the potential to sensitize patients is present. We hypothesized that higher amounts of wear particles result in increased release of metal ions and ultimately lead to an increased incidence of metal allergy. 52 hips in 52 patients (median age 60 (51-64) years, 30 women) were randomized to either a MOM hip resurfacing system (ReCap) or a standard MOP total hip arthoplasty (Mallory Head/Exeter). Spot urine samples were collected preoperatively, postoperatively, after 3 months, and after 1, 2, and 5 years and tested with inductively coupled plasma-sector field mass spectrometry. After 5 years, hypersensitivity to metals was evaluated by patch testing and lymphocyte transformation assay. In addition, the patients answered a questionnaire about hypersensitivity. A statistically significant 10- to 20-fold increase in urinary levels of cobalt and chromium was observed throughout the entire follow-up in the MOM group. The prevalence of metal allergy was similar between groups. While we observed significantly increased levels of metal ions in the urine during the entire follow-up period, no difference in prevalence of metal allergy was observed in the MOM group. However, the effect of long-term metal exposure remains uncertain.

MATERIALS

Product Number

Brand

Product Description

GF35446316

Titanium, rod, 100mm, diameter 20mm, annealed, 99.6+%

GF21200746

Titanium, tube, 100mm, outside diameter 0.81mm, inside diameter 0.61mm, wall thickness 0.1mm, as drawn, 99.6+%

GF99390134

Titanium, rod, 100mm, diameter 3.0mm, annealed, 99.6+%

GF73866998

Titanium, tube, 100mm, outside diameter 12.7mm, inside diameter 10.9mm, wall thickness 0.9mm, annealed, 99.6+%

GF39390880

Titanium, tube, 200mm, outside diameter 6.35mm, inside diameter 4.57mm, wall thickness 0.89mm, annealed, 99.6+%

GF29374005

Titanium, mesh, 100x100mm, nominal aperture 4.3mm, wire diameter 1.5mm, 4.4x4.4 wires/inch, open area 94%, platinized diamond mesh

GF75709457

Titanium, sphere, 100pcs, diameter 3mm, 99.6+%

GF35682600

Titanium, tube, 200mm, outside diameter 6.1mm, inside diameter 5.1mm, wall thickness 0.5mm, annealed, 99.6+%

GF83238127

Titanium, tube, 100mm, outside diameter 3.0mm, inside diameter 1.5mm, wall thickness 0.75mm, annealed, 99.6+%

GF73915128

Titanium, tube, 100mm, outside diameter 6.35mm, inside diameter 4.57mm, wall thickness 0.89mm, annealed, 99.6+%

GF82391878

Titanium, rod, 50mm, diameter 8.0mm, as drawn, 99.99+%

GF33373795

Titanium, tube, 200mm, outside diameter 12.7mm, inside diameter 10.9mm, wall thickness 0.9mm, annealed, 99.6+%

GF35130035

Titanium, rod, 25mm, diameter 9.5mm, annealed, 99.99+%

GF63527003

Titanium, tube, 200mm, outside diameter 9.5mm, inside diameter 8.2mm, wall thickness 0.65mm, annealed, 99.6+%

GF17395375

Titanium, tube, 1000mm, outside diameter 2.03mm, inside diameter 1.63mm, wall thickness 0.2mm, annealed, 99.6+%

268496

Sigma-Aldrich

Titanium, powder, −100 mesh, 99.7% trace metals basis

268526

Sigma-Aldrich

Titanium, sponge, 1-20 mm, 99.5% trace metals basis

ERMEC590

Polyethylene (LDPE), ERM^®, certified reference material

433667

Sigma-Aldrich

Titanium, evaporation slug, diam. × L 6.3 mm × 6.3 mm, ≥99.99% trace metals basis

267503

Sigma-Aldrich

Titanium, foil, thickness 0.25 mm, 99.7% trace metals basis

460397

Sigma-Aldrich

Titanium, foil, thickness 0.127 mm, ≥99.99% trace metals basis

348805

Sigma-Aldrich

Titanium, foil, thickness 0.5 mm, 99.99% trace metals basis

IRMM531A

Titanium, IRMM^®, certified reference material, 0.1 mm foil

348864

Sigma-Aldrich

Titanium, wire, diam. 0.5 mm, 99.99% trace metals basis

366994

Sigma-Aldrich

Titanium, powder, <45 μm avg. part. size, 99.98% trace metals basis

267481

Sigma-Aldrich

Titanium, foil, thickness 0.25 mm, 99.99% trace metals basis

767506

Sigma-Aldrich

Titanium, sputtering target, diam. × thickness 2.00 in. × 0.25 in., 99.995% trace metals basis

GF96944923

Titanium, wire reel, 5m, diameter 0.25mm, as drawn, 99.6+%

GF28054504

Titanium, wire reel, 500m, diameter 0.25mm, annealed, 99.6+%

GF62263841

Titanium, wire reel, 50m, diameter 0.125mm, annealed, 99.6+%