Skip to Content
Merck
  • Quantifying the sampling error in tree census measurements by volunteers and its effect on carbon stock estimates.

Quantifying the sampling error in tree census measurements by volunteers and its effect on carbon stock estimates.

Ecological applications : a publication of the Ecological Society of America (2013-07-20)
Nathalie Butt, Eleanor Slade, Jill Thompson, Yadvinder Malhi, Terhi Riutta
ABSTRACT

A typical way to quantify aboveground carbon in forests is to measure tree diameters and use species-specific allometric equations to estimate biomass and carbon stocks. Using "citizen scientists" to collect data that are usually time-consuming and labor-intensive can play a valuable role in ecological research. However, data validation, such as establishing the sampling error in volunteer measurements, is a crucial, but little studied, part of utilizing citizen science data. The aims of this study were to (1) evaluate the quality of tree diameter and height measurements carried out by volunteers compared to expert scientists and (2) estimate how sensitive carbon stock estimates are to these measurement sampling errors. Using all diameter data measured with a diameter tape, the volunteer mean sampling error (difference between repeated measurements of the same stem) was 9.9 mm, and the expert sampling error was 1.8 mm. Excluding those sampling errors > 1 cm, the mean sampling errors were 2.3 mm (volunteers) and 1.4 mm (experts) (this excluded 14% [volunteer] and 3% [expert] of the data). The sampling error in diameter measurements had a small effect on the biomass estimates of the plots: a volunteer (expert) diameter sampling error of 2.3 mm (1.4 mm) translated into 1.7% (0.9%) change in the biomass estimates calculated from species-specific allometric equations based upon diameter. Height sampling error had a dependent relationship with tree height. Including height measurements in biomass calculations compounded the sampling error markedly; the impact of volunteer sampling error on biomass estimates was +/- 15%, and the expert range was +/- 9%. Using dendrometer bands, used to measure growth rates, we calculated that the volunteer (vs. expert) sampling error was 0.6 mm (vs. 0.3 mm), which is equivalent to a difference in carbon storage of +/- 0.011 kg C/yr (vs. +/- 0.002 kg C/yr) per stem. Using a citizen science model for monitoring carbon stocks not only has benefits in educating and engaging the public in science, but as demonstrated here, can also provide accurate estimates of biomass or forest carbon stocks.

MATERIALS
Product Number
Brand
Product Description

Sigma-Aldrich
Activated Charcoal Norit®, Norit® RB3, for gas purification, steam activated, rod
Sigma-Aldrich
Activated Charcoal Norit®, Norit® PK 1-3, from peat, steam activated, granular
Sigma-Aldrich
Activated Charcoal Norit®, Norit® SX ultra, from peat, corresponds U.S. Food chemicals codex (3rd Ed.), steam activated and acid washed, highly purified, powder
Sigma-Aldrich
Activated Charcoal Norit®, Norit® SX2, powder, from peat, multi-purpose activated charcoal, steam activated and acid washed
Sigma-Aldrich
Activated Charcoal Norit®, Norit® GAC 1240W, from coal, for potable water processing, steam activated, granular
Sigma-Aldrich
Activated Charcoal Norit®, Norit® CA1, wood, chemically activated, powder
Sigma-Aldrich
Carbon, nanopowder, <100 nm particle size (TEM)
Millipore
Activated charcoal, suitable for GC
Supelco
Activated charcoal, powder
Supelco
Activated Charcoal Norit®, Norit® RBAA-3, rod
Sigma-Aldrich
Activated charcoal, suitable for cell culture, suitable for plant cell culture
Supelco
Activated charcoal, for the determination of AOX, 50-150 μm particle size
Supelco
Activated charcoal, puriss. p.a., powder
Sigma-Aldrich
Carbon, glassy, spherical powder, 2-12 μm, 99.95% trace metals basis
Sigma-Aldrich
Activated charcoal, powder, -100 particle size (mesh), decolorizing
Sigma-Aldrich
Activated charcoal, untreated, granular, 20-60 mesh
Sigma-Aldrich
Activated charcoal, acid-washed with hydrochloric acid
Sigma-Aldrich
Activated charcoal, acid-washed with phosphoric and sulfuric acids
Sigma-Aldrich
Activated charcoal, untreated, granular, ≤5 mm
Sigma-Aldrich
Activated charcoal, untreated, granular, 8-20 mesh
Sigma-Aldrich
Activated Charcoal, meets USP testing specifications
Sigma-Aldrich
Activated charcoal, DARCO®, 4-12 mesh particle size, granular
Sigma-Aldrich
Activated charcoal, DARCO®, 12-20 mesh, granular
Sigma-Aldrich
Activated charcoal, DARCO®, 20-40 mesh particle size, granular
Sigma-Aldrich
Activated charcoal, DARCO®, −100 mesh particle size, powder
Sigma-Aldrich
Activated charcoal, Norit® ROW 0.8 SUPRA, pellets